- Goal Diggers
- Guest Diggers
Sales Tax will kill Zambia’s mining industry, warns SaasaBy Stuart Lisulo on 29 Aug 2019
Renowned economist Professor Oliver Saasa says government’s determination to eventually implement the Goods and Services Tax (GST) on January 1, 2020, will eventually result in killing the mining sector because costs of production will drastically increase.
In a statement issued to Mining for Zambia, a Chamber of Mines initiative, Prof Saasa cautioned against rushing to implement the GST from next year, but instead maintain with the current existing Value Added Tax (VAT) system to avert a potentially disastrous situation where the major mining companies cease operations in the country.
In a detailed analysis between the two tax systems, Prof Saasa, the Premier Consult chief executive officer, explained that the GST would equally lead to less tax revenues being collected in the medium-term.
“If we had to compare both systems, they both collect [tax]. In certain sectors, as a government, you may collect a little bit more. But you have to look at the incentives — you can’t only focus on collection. If you negatively impact the goose that’s laying the golden egg, then you end up killing it. And then you discover that, in the medium to long-term, you will not collect anything,” Prof Saasa warned.
He pointed out that the GST implementation would result in reductions in tax collections in the medium-term.
“Whether or not Sales Tax will be implemented is still being debated, but if it’s passed in January, firstly, there will be a short-term increase in Treasury collections — but there will be a medium to long-term reduction in tax payments. That, for me, is a given,” he noted.
“Secondly, we will not see significant mining development in terms of expansion. And that would mean — because the tax regime is not good enough — Zambia slowly falling backwards on its projected growth in the mining sector, which is not good. You are talking about a sector that accounts for more than approximately 70 per cent of export receipts and revenue. That will disturb foreign exchange availability, interest rates, and it will disturb the value of the kwacha. We urgently need to address the issues with Sales Tax because a cough in the mining sector will give everybody in the country the Flu, so to speak.”
And he argued that part of government’s motivation to abandon VAT was to run away from their responsibility of paying off outstanding VAT refund claims, especially from mining companies.
“I think it’s important to understand what the main motivator is for abandoning the VAT that we adopted 25 years ago: It is all about how best the government can run away from meeting its obligations to refund VAT to the mines. There’s no economic reason whatsoever why we should migrate to Sales Tax,” he stated.
“For the government, whatever [VAT] gets into the kitty is like a profit, and they tend to consume it. When it comes to their obligation to pay VAT refunds, they have no other revenue source, unless they just go straight to the Treasury. When these refunds accumulate for such a long time, the amounts become atrocious. At the moment, we’re talking about approximately $5-600 million collectively owed just to the mining sector.”
On the challenges of the Sales Tax, Prof Saasa reiterated widespread concerns relating to its cascading effect on inflation, which remained on an upward trajectory.
“One of the challenges with a Sales Tax is the cascading [or compounding] effect. You have a situation where, at every point in the chain, you see the same percentage being added as a Sales Tax — either 16% or 9%, for imports or locally produced goods, over and over again. The total Sales Tax cost to the mines, for example, could be as high as 37.8%. Of course, this will push up the cost of production — and this is not only for the mines, but for almost everybody. This means that a number of the taxes that have been brought in will make reinvestment very problematic,” stated Prof Saasa.
“The whole idea of migrating from VAT to Sales Tax, from the government’s standpoint, is that they want to maximize tax collection, and the amount that goes to the Treasury. But, while the cascading effect of Sales Tax would create a semblance of more money going to the treasury through tax collection in the short term, by introducing Sales Tax, you are going to discourage investment in the mining sector. The reason being: the cost of reinvestment becomes higher.
Investors come here in order to harvest returns on their investment. So, immediately when the tax regime is not sufficiently attractive, they’d rather move out and go elsewhere — or scale down.”
Industry experts have consistently warned that government’s attempt to implement Sales Tax in its current form will trigger huge job losses along the supply chain owing to the threatening cascading effect of applying tax-on-tax, possibly forcing out distributors and rendering them obsolete.
About Stuart Lisulo
Stuart Lisulo is an experienced journalist with a focus on business news.
Email: stuart [at] diggers [dot] news
- Kwacha nears 19 per dollar - 2 Apr 2020
- Zesco’s demands to adjust BSA would’ve been injurious to our business – CEC - 2 Apr 2020
- COVID-19 will trigger major global economic recession, warns World Bank - 25 Mar 2020
- Lungu holds nation address on COVID-19 at 11:30hrs - 25 Mar 2020
- Multichoice explains movie rental fee hike - 23 Mar 2020
- We’re already on lockdown – Lungu (26,502 views)
- Kampyongo, Malanji, Lombe in quarantine after suspected exposure to COVID-19 (8,693 views)
- Kwamana for Lungu now, he has to go - KBF (8,587 views)
- Lungu's Cabinet leadership on COVID-19 scary (4,838 views)
- Name govt officials who are infected, in quarantine (4,683 views)
Subscribe for news email alerts
ArchivesMay0 PostsJun0 PostsJul0 PostsAug0 PostsSep0 PostsOct0 PostsNov0 PostsDec0 Posts
- «April 2020»
- April 2020
- March 2020
- February 2020
- January 2020
- December 2019
- November 2019
- October 2019
- September 2019
- August 2019
- July 2019
- June 2019
- May 2019
- April 2019
- March 2019
- February 2019
- January 2019
- December 2018
- November 2018
- October 2018
- September 2018
- August 2018
- July 2018
- June 2018
- May 2018
- April 2018
- March 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
- November 2017
- October 2017
- September 2017
- August 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
- About 10 Cancer Diseases Hospital doctors in quarantine
- Kwacha nears 19 per dollar
- I’ll test for COVID-19 on Friday, says Kampyongo
- Zambia records first COVID-19 death, community infections on the rise
- Pharmaceutical Society condemns Lusambo for harassing pharmacies
- About 10 Cancer Diseases Hospital doctors in quarantine
- Govt forecasts stability in mining sector amidst COVID-19 pandemic
- Come and get talk time to continue criticizing me, I won’t stop whipping people – Bowman
- Govt doesn’t yet need Parliament approval to contract debt – Solicitor General
- We’ll put KCM on care and maintenance if need be – Milingo
- Court puts 4 Linda rioters on their defense
- Zesco’s demands to adjust BSA would’ve been injurious to our business – CEC
The News Diggers
Deputy News Editor
Send this to a friend