by Omphile Ndlovu on 21 Sep 2019by Diggers Correspondent on 21 Sep 2019by Julia Malunga on 20 Sep 2019by Ulande Nkomesha on 20 Sep 2019
by Stuart Lisulo on 19 Sep 2019by Sipilisiwe Ncube on 19 Sep 2019by Julia Malunga on 17 Sep 2019by Stuart Lisulo on 17 Sep 2019
by Zondiwe Mbewe on 20 Sep 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 19 Sep 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 19 Sep 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 18 Sep 2019
- Goal Diggers
by Mazuba Muleya on 18 Sep 2019by Abraham Kalito on 17 Sep 2019by Abraham Kalito on 13 Sep 2019by Abraham Kalito on 13 Sep 2019
by Diggers Editor on 20 Sep 2019by Diggers Editor on 19 Sep 2019by Diggers Editor on 18 Sep 2019by Diggers Editor on 17 Sep 2019
- Guest Diggers
by Simon Manda, PhD on 16 Sep 2019by Simon Manda, PhD on 7 Sep 2019by pilAto/ Fumba Chama on 7 Sep 2019by Chisoni Mumba, PhD on 17 Aug 2019
- Editor's Choice
by Diggers Correspondent on 24 May 2019by Diggers Reporter on 4 Mar 2019by Andyford Mayele Banda on 29 Jan 2019by Davies Mwila on 22 Jan 2019
by Diggers Correspondent on 11 Aug 2019by Mukosha Funga on 27 Jul 2019by Mukosha Funga on 21 Jul 2019by Web Master on 27 Jun 2019
Commercialising FRA will stunt Agric sector growth – StakeholdersBy Mirriam Chabala on 13 Feb 2018
A group of civil society organisations and farmer associations says government’s decision to commercialise the Food Reserve Agency because that will severely undermine the development of Zambia’s agricultural sector.
During a consultative workshop held on December 6, 2017, government, through the Ministry of Agriculture, announced that it would review the FRA Act Chapter 225 of the laws of Zambia to allow the agency to purchase trade stock of designated commodities for local and export markets affecting both small holder farmers and consumers.
But in a statement, the group, comprising of the Zambia National Farmers Union (ZNFU), Grain Traders Association of Zambia (GTAZ), National Union of Small Scale Farmers of Zambia (NUSFAZ), Consumer Unity and Trust Society (CUTS), Centre for Trade Policy and Development (CTPD), and FoodTrade East and Southern Africa (FoodTrade ESA), the trade organisations observed that giving FRA the proposed powers would significantly weaken the private sector in Zambia.
“We welcome the government’s decision to review the operations of the FRA; this provides an opportunity to address key challenges associated with FRA, and provide learning to other countries in the region facing similar challenges. These include over dependence on government funding, high operating costs and unsustainable subsidies. We also recognise that some of the measures proposed such as defining the level of national strategic reserves, improving corporate governance and aligning the FRA’s financial year with the budget cycle could help improve food markets in Zambia. However, we, the Zambia National Farmers Union (ZNFU), Grain Traders Association of Zambia (GTAZ), National Union of Small Scale Farmers of Zambia (NUSFAZ), Consumer Unity and Trust Society (CUTS), Centre for Trade Policy and Development (CTPD), and FoodTrade East and Southern Africa (FoodTrade ESA) are deeply concerned by the proposal that the FRA should be given powers to buy and trade stock of designated commodities for local and export markets,” the statement read in part.
“Such a significant expansion of its role would severely undermine the development of Zambia’s agricultural sector, affecting both small holder farmers and consumers. It would significantly weaken the private sector in Zambia, which contravenes the government’s commitment to reduce its role in the agricultural sector. The 7NDP, the Zambia CAADP Compact, National Agricultural Policy, the Zambia Plus and the PF 2016 Agricultural Manifesto, all recommend that agriculture should be private-sector led. If the proposed amendments to the FRA Act are implemented, they would severely undermine the private sector in Zambian agriculture.”
They stated that contrary to the Ministry of Agriculture projection that the move could make FRA financially viable, the agency could not make profits from exports.
“The Ministry of Agriculture argue that the FRA can become commercially viable by raising revenue through exports. But the assumption underpinning this argument is flawed and contradictory. FRA cannot simultaneously make a profit through exports and stabilise prices. Nor can it make a profit and support farmers, which it has traditionally done by offering them an above market-price,” the statement read.
And the trade organisations stated that one major consequence of reviewing the FRA Act would be the loss of private investment in agriculture and reduced opportunities to diversify the economy.
“The proposed amendments would in effect recreate the National Agricultural Marketing Board (NAMBOARD), which had to be abolished because it proved highly ineffectual, and badly damaged agricultural-led development in Zambia. We are yet to come across a country that has successfully implemented the commercialisation of their food reserve agency and our concern is that expanding the role of the FRA could further burden the Treasury and the Zambian taxpayer. Such an outcome would be particularly harmful to the Zambian economy at a time Zambia is seeking to undertake fiscal consolidation. International evidence and the experience in Zambia demonstrate that the best way to address the concerns about financial unsustainability and high operating costs of the FRA is to scale back its role to focus on providing the country with a strategic grain reserve and servicing remote areas which are inaccessible to the private sector,” read the statement.
“These amendments are concerning and risk negating the small gains made within Zambia’s agriculture sector. One consequence of such a move would be the loss of private investment in agriculture, and reduced opportunities to diversify the economy. Further to this, such a move would have significant negative impacts on the Zambian Commodities Exchange (ZAMACE). On this basis, we recommend that the Ministry of Agriculture drops the proposed amendments aimed at commercialising FRA and engage further with stakeholders to develop a set of evidence-based reforms that help agriculture in Zambia grow.”
About Mirriam Chabala
Mirriam covers current affairs and writes in-depth feature articles on social issues.
Email: mirriam [at] diggers [dot] news
- AVAP partners with German firm in demanding better service delivery from councils - 20 Sep 2019
- Chapter One ticks Lungu for admitting economic malaise - 19 Sep 2019
- About 50,000 teachers can’t find jobs anywhere, reveals NAQEZ - 19 Sep 2019
- German Envoy salutes Diggers; it’s the only newspaper that strives to investigate - 18 Sep 2019
- Kambwili is already a dead man, no one can kill him – Mumbi - 13 Sep 2019
- Thanks to Goswami, Lungu’s chickens are coming home to roost (12,890 views)
- PF need a miracle to pass Bill 10 – Nkombo (2,068 views)
- UK responds with relief food to hunger disaster (2,062 views)
- Lungu’s continued association with Findlay damaging the Presidency - KBF (1,504 view)
- Power is like buttocks, when you go up, prepare to go down (1,038 view)
- Zesco tariffs to go up by 75%, we also need to revise fuel prices - Minister
- HH shouldn’t be moving around like a cockroach in the kitchen - Bowman
- Germany ambassador offers to help FAZ find a coach
- Airtel agent in court for defiling wife’s sisters
- We warned Lungu over his friendship with Valden Findlay
Subscribe For News In Email
The News Diggers
Deputy News Editor
Plot No. Lus/9812/649-MC8
off Alex Chola Road
P.O. Box 32147
Telephone or WhatsApp:
diggers [at] diggers [dot] news
editor [at] diggers [dot] news
Send this to a friend