by Sipilisiwe Ncube on 23 May 2019by Thomas Mulenga on 23 May 2019by Mirriam Chabala on 23 May 2019by Sipilisiwe Ncube on 23 May 2019
- Goal Diggers
by Zondiwe Mbewe on 23 May 2019by Mukosha Funga on 23 May 2019by Mukosha Funga on 23 May 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 22 May 2019
- Editor's Choice
by Diggers Reporter on 4 Mar 2019by Andyford Mayele Banda on 29 Jan 2019by Davies Mwila on 22 Jan 2019by Diggers Reporter on 17 Jan 2019
by Diggers Editor on 23 May 2019by Diggers Editor on 22 May 2019by Diggers Editor on 21 May 2019by Diggers Editor on 18 May 2019
by Sipilisiwe Ncube on 23 May 2019by Sampa Kabwela on 18 May 2019by Felix Kashweka on 16 May 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 26 Apr 2019
- Guest Diggers
by Guest Digger on 22 May 2019by Chibamba Kanyama on 21 May 2019by Dr Munyonzwe Hamalengwa on 19 May 2019by Rueben Lifuka on 16 May 2019
Depending on donor funds for mandatory HIV testing is dangerous, warns Dr Manase PhiriBy Sipilisiwe Ncube and Mukosha Funga on 25 Aug 2017
Renowned HIV activist Dr Manasse Phiri says as government embarks on an ambitious path of testing everyone and putting those with HIV on ART treatment, there is need to look for domestic sources of funding so that it can be sustained once donors pull out.
And Dr Phiri says President Edgar Lungu cannot close debate about mandatory HIV testing because there is need for further clarifications.
Meanwhile, Dr Phiri says it is highly discriminatory to make statements that no one has the right to take someone else’s life by infecting them with HIV.
Speaking when he phoned in during 5FM’s ‘The Burning Issue’ program yesterday, Dr Phiri observed that the money used for testing and treating HIV was all from donors.
“We have so many other things that we need to sort out, this political leadership in our country, they say they want to know the exact people who are positive so we can put them on treatment. That money for treatment, that money for testing is not our money. What if Donald Trump says ‘no more HIV money to Zambia’ where will people go? What are we going to do? So alongside what we are talking about, we need to be talking about domestic financing, how are we going to raise money so that we are able to pay for every Zambian who is on treatment? It must be now. We don’t talk about HIV in our prisons, we don’t even allow condoms in prisons. What about adolescent reproductive health? We have 16,000 girls getting out of school because they are pregnant, how many of those are catching HIV? It is a calamity for the nation but we don’t seem to worry as a nation, we just keep debating about compulsory,” Dr Phiri said.
And Dr Phiri said there was need for more debates on the mandatory testing policy because there were many unanswered questions.
“And what I am hearing about this mandatory testing, or compulsory testing now by the Minister and by other people is that we are talking about routine testing, and that I support totally. Mandatory testing, compulsory testing is almost punitive and the Doctors there describes to you what happens in some countries. Just by being somebody from Zambia, from Africa, you can’t enter the country, if it is positive, they will not allow you to go to Australia because it is mandatory, it is compulsory testing,” Dr Phiri said.
“But where the President said ‘this is it and no debate’ and here we are debating. I mean he couldn’t close the chapter like that and it’s better if it needed clarification and if indeed people wanted to take him to court, they could have and they still can if he is insisting that this is mandatory testing where police are going to wait by the door if you refuse to test, they push you in, it means you have committed a crime. There are people who were getting ready to seek court action because it sounded punitive; it sounded like a punishment for people who were going to refuse to test.”
Meanwhile, Dr Phiri said it was discriminatory to state that no one had the right to take someone else’s life by infecting them with HIV.
“But what am hearing, what we are talking about now is routine testing and we need to make that very clear because as the Dr says, it has that option that if somebody doesn’t want to be tested, they can say so but with guidelines from the government or from the Ministry of what then do we do with that person because of the way it has gone out to the public and social media of a person who is being bundled by police because he apparently refused to test,” he said.
“So what will happen to people if they refuse to test if indeed it’s mandatory? And I think we need to get clarification on this. We don’t need to be emotional about this, we need to sit as a country together ourselves as activists and pure doctors and politicians who are making these pronouncements, we need to be sure that we are all speaking the same language. I have worked in HIV since the very early 1980s and I am yet to meet one person who is proud to be HIV positive, who deliberately becomes infected, it’s something that is dreaded. So we must stop stigmatizing and discriminating by saying nobody has the right to infect anybody, nobody has the right to kill. We know that already and even the people with HIV know that.”
He also said President Edgar Lungu should have led by example by publicly testing for HIV after the launch instead of his team only flashing pictures where he was checking his blood pressure levels.
“It [the mandatory testing pronouncement] does [make me happy] in a small way. It is the first time that a Head of State has made a pronouncement regarding how we are going to deal with this epidemic from that level but unfortunately, the leadership in leading by example did not happen. I was so amazed that the pictures that were on social media, in our newspapers were of the President having his blood pressure checked, he wasn’t launching a blood pressure problem. He was launching a testing and counseling and treatment program. How much impact would it have had if he had tested with whoever in his Cabinet there?” Dr Phiri asked.
He also warned that counselors could not be trusted to maintain confidentiality like doctors.
“The way we have been testing for HIV, the people in the frontlines are not doctors, the majority of them are lay counselors so they may not be as bound by medical ethics as we would like and it is something that we should bear in mind. If we are going to go in this new way, who will be in the front lines? Will it be doctors or nurses or are we still going to use counselors who are going to say ‘look, you have tested positive now I am going to connect you to treatment’,” he said.
Dr Phiri further said there was need for innovative ways of persuading more men to test for HIV.
“And also, this confusion, why we are talking about this, I think it is a nomenclature; mandatory vs compulsory vs routine. What my good president of the ZMA has been describing is routine testing with an option to opt out. And it didn’t always happen, the idea was if a woman becomes pregnant and comes to the antenatal clinic and they are going to take blood from her for all the other tests that we do, they will take for HIV as well unless she said ‘no, I don’t want this’. So she gives consent and as it was explained that yes it has worked wonderfully,” said Dr Phiri.
“Men don’t go for testing, they don’t go for medical examinations, men are culprits. Even when they are tested and are put on treatment, more men are dying because they are not complying with the treatment. So what we need are innovative ways of persuading more men to test, of fining men in places where they are and where they feel it is safe to test them rather than anybody coming to the clinic to be tested, we are not going to win this battle like that.”
About Sipilisiwe Ncube
Sipilisiwe Ncube is a Zambian journalist with a background in radio news.
Email: sipilisiwe [at] diggers [dot] news
- Lungu is tolerant, despite being most insulted President – Sunday - 23 May 2019
- Any investor who’ll takeover KCM will have serious fears – Milupi - 23 May 2019
- ActionAid supports KCM liquidation, cautions against politically inclined handlers - 23 May 2019
- Man stabbed to death after refusing to buy round of Kachasu - 23 May 2019
- Police storm Prime TV, demand footage of Defamation of the President suspects - 23 May 2019
About Mukosha Funga
Mukosha Funga is a Zambian journalist interested in good governance and anti corruption reporting.
- I didn’t know my brother was part of Tokota Boys, witness tells court - 23 May 2019
- Court of Appeal upholds Mukata’s death sentence - 23 May 2019
- Since inception, KCM has only paid US$58m dividends, ZCCM-IH tells court - 22 May 2019
- I didn’t say there’re no problems in the economy, Amos clarifies - 22 May 2019
- High Court orders Diamond General Insurance to compensate Downtown mall Complex repairs - 21 May 2019
- Gunshots fired as KCM liquidator storms Chingola to takeover assets
- I didn't believe mum when she said 'hubby' is my brother, incest accused tells court
- Court of Appeal upholds Mukata's death sentence
- Chomba Kaoma reports Kaizer to police for slapping him
- CK vows to prove Mwila hired someone to write his G12 exams
- Lungu is tolerant, despite being most insulted President – Sunday
- Amos says Lungu is worried with opposition plans to kill ‘NDF Bill’ in Parliament
- Cuban Envoy seeks Zambia’s solidarity against US sanctions
- Any investor who’ll takeover KCM will have serious fears – Milupi
- There is no room for public scrutiny of NDF resolutions as Lungu claims – Chanda
Subscribe for email alerts
ArchivesJun0 PostsJul0 PostsAug0 PostsSep0 PostsOct0 PostsNov0 PostsDec0 Posts
- May 2019
- April 2019
- March 2019
- February 2019
- January 2019
- December 2018
- November 2018
- October 2018
- September 2018
- August 2018
- July 2018
- June 2018
- May 2018
- April 2018
- March 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
- November 2017
- October 2017
- September 2017
- August 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
The News Diggers
Deputy News Editor
Plot No. Lus/9812/649-MC8
off Alex Chola Road
P.O. Box 32147
Telephone or WhatsApp:
diggers [at] diggers [dot] news
editor [at] diggers [dot] news
Send this to a friend