by Ulande Nkomesha on 19 Jul 2019by Julia Malunga on 19 Jul 2019by Ulande Nkomesha on 19 Jul 2019by Mirriam Chabala on 19 Jul 2019
- Goal Diggers
by Mirriam Chabala on 18 Jul 2019by Natasha Sakala on 18 Jul 2019by Diggers Correspondent on 18 Jul 2019by Joseph Mwenya in Kabwe on 17 Jul 2019
by Zondiwe Mbewe on 19 Jul 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 18 Jul 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 18 Jul 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 18 Jul 2019
- Editor's Choice
by Diggers Correspondent on 24 May 2019by Diggers Reporter on 4 Mar 2019by Andyford Mayele Banda on 29 Jan 2019by Davies Mwila on 22 Jan 2019
by Diggers Editor on 19 Jul 2019by Diggers Editor on 16 Jul 2019by Diggers Editor on 14 Jul 2019by Diggers Editor on 13 Jul 2019
by Web Master on 27 Jun 2019by Mirriam Chabala on 26 Jun 2019by Martha Mwanza and Felix Kashweka on 21 Jun 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 7 Jun 2019
- Guest Diggers
by Dr Chisoni Mumba, PhD on 22 Jun 2019by Chewe Chishala on 22 Jun 2019by Chibamba Kanyama on 11 Jun 2019by Chibamba Kanyama on 28 May 2019
Matibini rules Maggie out of order for lying to Parley on declining reservesBy Mirriam Chabala on 22 Mar 2019
Speaker of the National Assembly Patrick Matibini says Finance Minister Margaret Mwanakatwe mislead the nation last year when she gave two contradictory statements regarding the decline in the country’s foreign exchange reserves.
Speaker Matibini, however, neither ordered Mwanakatwe to apologise nor censured her.
On that day, Mwanakatwe had informed the House that that the country’s reserves had declined by 28% from USD$2.9 billion at the end of January 2016 to USD $2.1 billion by the end of December, 2017.
And when asked why the country’s reserves had declined by Moomba UPND member of parliament Fred Chaatila, the minister explained that it was because government had been partly using the reserves to service interest payments on the Euro Bond debt.
The minister’s response prompted Kapiri-Mposhi UPND member of parliament Stanley Kakubo to ask a supplementary question, requesting her to explain when her ministry would go back to the House and give a detailed list of how government spent the Euro bond.
But first deputy Speaker of the National Assembly Catherine Namugula hesitated to give the minister an opportunity to respond, given that the question asked by the Kapiri-Mposhi lawmaker was outside the question on the order of the day.
The minister, however, volunteered a response; “We [as government] use our own earnings to pay Euro bond interests. The honourable member of parliament for Kapiri-Mponshi should please take that information to his people. I am also telling the nation now that we do not use reserves to pay Euro bond interests. I was paying Euro bond interest last week, my reserves were 1.7 last week. If you check my reserve today, they are the same. Osanama boza (do not spread falsehoods).”
It was at this point that Kakubo rose on a point of order seeking the Speaker’s ruling on whether the Minister of Finance was in order to backtrack on her earlier statement and mislead the House by responding to a similar question with two different and contradictory positions.
And in her immediate response, the first Deputy Speaker reserved her ruling, saying she needed to investigate the matter. But having studied the matter, Speaker Matibini ruled, Tuesday, that Mwanakatwe was out of order when she gave two contradictory statements on the floor of the House and as a consequence misled the House.
“Honourable members, the point of order raises the issue of a member’s duty to ensure that the information provided to the House when debating is factual and verifiable. The House is aware that the law and the rules of the House circumscribe the freedom of speech and debate that members enjoy in the House. One such restraint is a requirement for members to debate factually and in so doing, avoid all manner of misleading the House. The various sources of Parliamentary practice and procedure attest to this requirement. To begin with, section 16 (Powers and Privileges Act) makes it an offence for any person to intentionally mislead the House. It states as follows ‘any person who before the Assembly or a Committee) intentionally gives a false answer to any question material to the subject inquiry which may be put to him during the course of any examination shall be guilty of an offence against section 104 of the penal code’. Further, standing order 53 of the National Assembly of Zambia, standing orders 2016, obligates a member to debate factually. It states ‘a member shall in debating any matter ensure that the information he or she provides to the House is factual and verifiable’. Furthermore, the National Assembly members handbook 2006 in chapter three states as follows; ‘members must not allege specific matters or facts as being true unless they are able to substantiate them’,” Speaker Matibini said.
Matibini gave an account of how the National Assembly had handled the issue of members of parliament giving false information in the past.
“My predecessor had occasioned to guide the House on the matter of a member misleading the House in debates in the ruling in the case of R. Musokotwane nd honourable ML Kaingu, found in Parliamentary debates of the third meeting of the first session of the 9th National Assembly, 16th January to 27th March, 2009, at page 3111. In that matter, Honourable ML. Kaingu raised a point of order on the floor of the House, accusing Mrs R. Musokotwane MP of requesting him to remove some settlers from Chifulu Game Management area, which was in her constituency. However, it turned out that the statement by Honourable ML. Kaingu was false. Honourable ML. Kaingu, MP was found in breach of Parliamentary privilenge for making a false statement on the floor of the House and was admonished by the House and in rendering the ruling on the matter, my predecessor said as follows; ‘honourable members, while freedom of speech and action in the House are said to be unquestioned and free, there are certain restraints on the use of the right within the halls of the House…it is an offence punishable by the House for any person to willfully mislead the House’,” Matibini said.
“Therefore, honourable members of the House have a duty to ensure that they carefully verify their information before submitting the same to the House. This is important because the House in making decisions relies on the information submitted by members.”
About Mirriam Chabala
Mirriam Chabala covers current affairs and writes in-depth feature articles on social issues.
Email: mirriam [at] diggers [dot] news
- Police quick to arrest Lubinda’s attackers but failing to find Kasongo’s killers – NDC - 19 Jul 2019
- Govt will administer conventional FISP alongside e-voucher to address climate change – Katambo - 19 Jul 2019
- Nothing wrong with selling KCM to Chinese – Negotiating team - 18 Jul 2019
- ZCCB seeks alternative route for “genuine” reconciliation - 18 Jul 2019
- CCPC seizes goods worth K6,000 in Muchinga - 18 Jul 2019
- Proposal to take away Parliament’s approval for loan contraction retrogressive – CTPD
- Independent MPs can’t stop Bill with compromised UPND – Chabi
- Lungu’s re-election campaign draining Treasury – Chipimo
- Police quick to arrest Lubinda’s attackers but failing to find Kasongo’s killers – NDC
- We don’t mind Chinese taking KCM, as long as they pay mine suppliers – Association
Subscribe for email alerts
ArchivesAug0 PostsSep0 PostsOct0 PostsNov0 PostsDec0 Posts
- July 2019
- June 2019
- May 2019
- April 2019
- March 2019
- February 2019
- January 2019
- December 2018
- November 2018
- October 2018
- September 2018
- August 2018
- July 2018
- June 2018
- May 2018
- April 2018
- March 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
- November 2017
- October 2017
- September 2017
- August 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
The News Diggers
Deputy News Editor
Plot No. Lus/9812/649-MC8
off Alex Chola Road
P.O. Box 32147
Telephone or WhatsApp:
diggers [at] diggers [dot] news
editor [at] diggers [dot] news
Send this to a friend