- Goal Diggers
- Guest Diggers
Bill 10 a product of PF – MwiimbuBy Ulande Nkomesha on 19 Feb 2020
LEADER of the Opposition Jack Mwiimbu says government should stop lying that the clauses in Bill 10 were engineered by the National Dialogue Forum when delegates have expressed ignorance about where some of the clauses came from.
And PF Deputy chief whip Tutwa Ngulube says if enacted, Bill 10 will create autonomy in the Judiciary.
Speaking during a public discussion organised by the Law Association of Zambia (LAZ), Eastern Province Minister Makebi Zulu said Bill 10 was not a reflection of what Cabinet wanted, but that it was a document crafted by NDF.
“This Bill 10 is not a white paper, it is not a reflection of what Cabinet wants. This is what came out of the National Dialogue Forum, a part of which LAZ was. LAZ the association I belong to participated fully in coming up with this particular documentation. I would have expected that upon the participation of the four members of LAZ, perhaps a report should have been given to the Law Association of Zambia as to what exactly transpired and what exactly was arrived at; and perhaps even before LAZ participated, LAZ should have come up or called such a meeting so that we discuss as members of LAZ and come up with a position on each and every clause,” said Zulu.
“All the provisions we let in the Judiciary were proposed by the Judiciary themselves. So if they were produced by the Judiciary themselves as to how exactly they would like their institution to be run, then it is within the province to be able to respond to the issues as regards to the composition, how it is supposed to be run. This is not a white paper, this is what came out of the NDF proposals that were brought by the judiciary for the purposes of improving their functionality as a Judiciary so these are the proposals that were raised by the Judiciary themselves.”
But Mwiimbu, who is Monze Central member of parliament, said Bill 10 was a product of PF.
“I would like to make one clarification. I have heard my colleague honourable Makebi Zulu saying that this is not a bill for the PF, this is not a bill for government; it is a bill for the NDF. Honourable members in parliament and in this country, there are only two types of bills that are presented to Parliament; government bill and private member bills. This particular bill number 10 is a government bill, it is not a bill for NDF or it is not a bill for LAZ; this is a bill that has been crafted and presented on the floor of the House by the government of the day led by the PF. So let us clear that misconception. And we are also aware that even those who were at the NDF they have argued that some of clauses in Bill 10 were not discussed at the NDF; that is on record. So we cannot say that everything here was arrived at NDF, it is not correct,” Mwiimbu said.
He said Bill 10 would cause problems in the Judiciary if enacted because it did not clearly state the powers of the president of the Constitutional Court.
“Bill 10 is creating a problem even before it is implemented. We should not allow these lacunas which we are deliberately creating. It is not prudent for me to state what is in Bill 10 but I should state what the people of Zambia wanted. The people of Zambia in the quest to cure the problems that are with the Constitutional Court; the people of Zambia had aspired to ensure that the Supreme Court of Zambia becomes the Constitutional Court like what is obtaining in other countries South Africa and other jurisdictions; that is what they have been wanting. Tagging on to what honourable (Tutwa) Ngulube has been saying, we have a problem wHere the Constitutional Court which is according to him is supposed to subservient to the Supreme Court is making final decisions; because you are saying the Chief Justice was not in that court, so it means that they cannot report! But all what you have done is you have just inserted a clause that the Chief Justice shall also be part of the supreme court but you have remained with the President; what will be the powers of the president of the Constitutional Court? You have a president who reports to somebody, to a governor, you are creating another problem in the Constitutional Court,” Mwiimbu said.
“If you wanted to cure the constitution, you should have been very clear pertaining to the jurisdiction; you attempted to do the jurisdiction but you talked about composition without talking about jurisdiction. What will happen now? The Chief Justice will descend to sit in the Constitutional Court? Who will be the head there? It becomes a problem! Because you would have not cured the mischief that was created by the constitution.”
He said Zambians wanted an independent and impartial Judiciary by ensuring that there was transparency in the appointment of judges.
“The issues which my colleagues have been talking about, the issue of saying 14 days visa vis 30 days is neither here nor there; even 30 day may not be enough; even one year may not be enough. It depends on how the judges behave. Even 30 days may not be enough; they may not even conclude, that is not even a solution. The solution is to have an independent and impartial Judiciary and that is what the people of Zambia want,” said Mwiimbu.
“This comes about by ensuring that appointments of those who aspire to be judges is transparent that is what the people have been crying for, not just pasting provisions that ‘no now let us also put the Chief justice then things we change’, it will not change. Even what we are now proposing to start, how we are going to be removing the judges, that is also comprising the security of tenure on the part of the judges and the judiciary has complained!”
And in his submission, Ngulube said Bill 10, if enacted, was going to create autonomy in the Judiciary.
“If you look at article 136 of the 2016 constitution, it says ‘there shall be a Chief Justice who is the head of the Judicary; (2) the Chief Justice shall be, that is 2 (a), responsible for the administration of the Judiciary and in (b) ensure that a judge and a judicial officer performs the judicial functions with dignity, propriety and integrity; and in (c) describe procedures to ensure that the judge and the judicial officer independently exercise judicial duty in accordance with the law. Article (138) says there shall be a president of a Constitutional Court who is the head of the Constitutional Court, [article] (136) says Chief Justice head of Judiciary; 138 says president of the Constitutional Court, head of the Constitutional Court. The President of the Constitutional Court shall be responsible for the administration of the Constitutional Court under the direction of the Chief Justice,” said Ngulube before the event was disrupted.
“So now the question here is if the Chief Justice who is supposed to control the President of the ConCourt is not part of the ConCourt then it will amount to interference; because the same constitution says a judicial officer shall not be interfered with; no one shall control in fact no single person or authority! Bill number 10 is actually trying to create autonomy in the Judiciary by ensuring that the Judiciary is independent. In bill number 10, we are saying not even the president of the ConCourt should be subject to the Chief Justice; we don’t want the president of the ConCourt to be subject of the authority of Chief Justice. We want him or her to be autonomous. Bill number 10 is actually creating an autonomy.”
About Ulande Nkomesha
Ulande is a reporter with an experience in radio broadcasting. He loves following current affairs and interacting with politicians.
Email: ulande [at] diggers [dot] news
- I’ll test for COVID-19 on Friday, says Kampyongo - 2 Apr 2020
- Zambia records first COVID-19 death, community infections on the rise - 2 Apr 2020
- Govt forecasts stability in mining sector amidst COVID-19 pandemic - 2 Apr 2020
- Lungu gives incentives to health workers fighting COVID-19 - 2 Apr 2020
- Whipping people patronising bars against human rights – Kasonde - 1 Apr 2020
- We’re already on lockdown – Lungu (24,290 views)
- Kampyongo, Malanji, Lombe in quarantine after suspected exposure to COVID-19 (8,400 views)
- Kwamana for Lungu now, he has to go - KBF (8,358 views)
- Lungu's Cabinet leadership on COVID-19 scary (4,634 views)
- Name govt officials who are infected, in quarantine (4,276 views)
Subscribe for news email alerts
ArchivesMay0 PostsJun0 PostsJul0 PostsAug0 PostsSep0 PostsOct0 PostsNov0 PostsDec0 Posts
- «April 2020»
- April 2020
- March 2020
- February 2020
- January 2020
- December 2019
- November 2019
- October 2019
- September 2019
- August 2019
- July 2019
- June 2019
- May 2019
- April 2019
- March 2019
- February 2019
- January 2019
- December 2018
- November 2018
- October 2018
- September 2018
- August 2018
- July 2018
- June 2018
- May 2018
- April 2018
- March 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
- November 2017
- October 2017
- September 2017
- August 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
- About 10 Cancer Diseases Hospital doctors in quarantine
- Kwacha nears 19 per dollar
- I’ll test for COVID-19 on Friday, says Kampyongo
- Zambia records first COVID-19 death, community infections on the rise
- Pharmaceutical Society condemns Lusambo for harassing pharmacies
- About 10 Cancer Diseases Hospital doctors in quarantine
- Govt forecasts stability in mining sector amidst COVID-19 pandemic
- Come and get talk time to continue criticizing me, I won’t stop whipping people – Bowman
- Govt doesn’t yet need Parliament approval to contract debt – Solicitor General
- We’ll put KCM on care and maintenance if need be – Milingo
- Court puts 4 Linda rioters on their defense
- Zesco’s demands to adjust BSA would’ve been injurious to our business – CEC
The News Diggers
Deputy News Editor
Send this to a friend