by Ulande Nkomesha on 14 Oct 2019by Julia Malunga on 14 Oct 2019by Julia Malunga on 14 Oct 2019by Julia Malunga on 14 Oct 2019
by Ulande Nkomesha on 13 Oct 2019by Ulande Nkomesha on 11 Oct 2019by Natasha Sakala on 11 Oct 2019by Sipilisiwe Ncube on 10 Oct 2019
by Zondiwe Mbewe on 14 Oct 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 14 Oct 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 11 Oct 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 11 Oct 2019
- Goal Diggers
by Abraham Kalito on 8 Oct 2019by Abraham Kalito on 7 Oct 2019by By Tim Zulu and Abraham Kalito on 7 Oct 2019by Abraham Kalito on 4 Oct 2019
by Diggers Editor on 13 Oct 2019by Diggers Editor on 11 Oct 2019by Diggers Editor on 10 Oct 2019by Diggers Editor on 9 Oct 2019
- Guest Diggers
by Simon Manda, PhD on 14 Oct 2019by Chisoni Mumba, PhD on 30 Sep 2019by Douty Chibamba on 25 Sep 2019by Chibamba Kanyama on 25 Sep 2019
- Editor's Choice
by Diggers Correspondent on 24 May 2019by Diggers Reporter on 4 Mar 2019by Andyford Mayele Banda on 29 Jan 2019by Davies Mwila on 22 Jan 2019
by Felix Kashweka on 4 Oct 2019by Diggers Correspondent on 28 Sep 2019by Douty Chibamba on 25 Sep 2019by Ulande Nkomesha on 24 Sep 2019
Re-launching national airline a gamble Zambia can’t afford – CTPDBy Mirriam Chabala on 21 Feb 2019
The Centre for Trade Policy and Development (CTPD) has insisted that government’s position to re-launch the Zambia Airways is a gamble which the country will not afford.
CTPD Researcher Bright Chizonde recently conducted a study focusing on Zambia’s plans to relaunch the National Airline and unveiled a number of lessons that Zambia could draw from countries like South Africa, Malawi and Ethiopia on the potential risks and success prospects of running a national airline.
Chizonde noted that even though the Ministry of Transport and Communication had already established a Board of Directors and appointed a Chief Executive Officer for Zambia Airways, it was important to consider how other African countries had fared in the aviation industry.
“South African Airways (SAA) is one of the Largest Airlines in Africa with about 50 aircrafts, including the Airbus A319, A320, A340 and Boeing 737 airplanes. SAA was established in 1934 and in terms of operations the airline has been making losses since 2011, with losses amounting to US$127million in 2016 and US$475million in 2017. Consequently, SAA has been bailed out by its government to the tune of US$1.2 billion in 2018 alone and it has been estimated that the airline will need a further US$1.8 billion to remain operational till 2021 when it is expected to breakeven. Would this be a path Zambia would want to take?” Chizonde wondered.
Chizonde highlighted some of the reasons why SAA was not performing well and some of the lessons that Zambia could learn from them.
“South African Airways operates in the southern African hub, this makes South African Airlines lack strategic location when it comes to long haul flights. Therefore, SAA’s hub in South Africa is distant from most international business, trade and tourism destinations. This notwithstanding, South Africa has a huge population size of about 56.7 million people and large economy with GDP of about US$349 billion translating into a large middle class which demands for air travel. Zambia, in contrast, has a relatively small middle class since the population is smaller, about 16 million people) and the GDP is less than US$ 30 billion. In terms of regional location, Zambia is also disadvantaged when it comes to intercontinental air travel,” Chizonde stated.
“Then SAA operates in a highly competitive regional and domestic industry, which squeezes profits. It competes with British Airways, operated by Comair regionally, as well as other 5 international airlines: Ethiopian Airlines, Emirates, Kenya Airways, TAAG Angola and Air Namibia. In the domestic market, SAA has sister carriers; Airlink and South African Express which compete with Fastjet, FlySafair and Kulula.com-which is a division of British Airways. Like most National airlines SAA has been financed through government investment and bailouts. This places a huge burden on government tax revenue which would otherwise be used for service delivery. In setting-up a national airline, Zambia exposes the already constrained fiscal position to additional risks and funding needs.”
Chizonde also listed government interference and poor management as one sure reason why SAA had failed, which was expected to be the case with Zambia Airways as well.
“South Africa does not only bailout its national airline but also exerts considerable interference in its operations. In 2012, the entire Board of Directors resigned in protest to interference from government. It is imperative that the Zambian government takes this to heart and avoids interfering in the operations of Zambia Airways in order to increase prospects for success. SAA has also been cited for poor management, the 2007 Auditor general’s report revealed that SAA had failed to properly record financial information and the value of its assets. It was also said to have employed too many workers and had a pay scale for top management which was way above industry norms,” Chizonde stated.
“Questions that beg for answers in the Zambian case also speaks to revelations contained in the auditor general’s reports and Financial Trends Report, to what extent is there accountability? What measures have we put in place that assures that there will be prudent use of resources that are channeled towards the airline, what is informing our conviction on the perceived returns and benefits?… let’s not forget that Zambia Airways previously went under due to some of these reasons shared above, particularly a lack of regional demand and financial mismanagement, and one wonders whether we have really learnt from the past.”
Chizonde insisted that Zambia’s current fiscal position could not allow for a massive experiment in the risky aviation industry at the expense of tax payers.
“Zambia is grappling with rapidly increasing debt, now about US$16billion, and is currently implementing austerity measures. Furthermore, it is extremely difficult to make profits in the aviation sector with African airlines expected to make a combined loss of about US$ 100 million in 2018, and slow economic growth in Southern Africa limiting passenger demand increases to 2-3% per year, below the 5% threshold needed to support a new entrant such as Zambian Airways. CTPD therefore considers the move towards re-launching Zambia Airways at this present time a gamble that the country can ill afford. South Africa is a classic example of the tax-revenue demands of running a national airline and the pitfalls to avoid. Zambia needs to consider whether it wants to end up increasing its current stock of public debt all in the name of national pride and whether the so-called economic benefits of re-launching the airline would outweigh these likely costs,” stated Chizonde.
About Mirriam Chabala
Mirriam covers current affairs and writes in-depth feature articles on social issues.
Email: mirriam [at] diggers [dot] news
- Debt repayments mustn’t impede social sector spending in 2020 budget – ZTP - 10 Oct 2019
- UPND accuses Siamunene of exploiting hunger crisis to make political comeback - 9 Oct 2019
- Corruption, tribalism must be key prayer points on Oct 18 – CCZ - 8 Oct 2019
- It was impossible to consult everyone on Bill 10 – Lubinda - 4 Oct 2019
- Foote urges Zambian youth to get tested for HIV - 4 Oct 2019
- Too late for Ng’andu to catch the Patriotic Front runaway train (2,046 views)
- Kalaluka fights LAZ's subpoenas against himself, Lubinda (1,119 view)
- UPND starts legal action against PF over "gay rights lies" (1,029 view)
- Don’t blame climate change but corruption for economic crisis - KBF (1,005 view)
- UNZA congratulates Prof Nalubamba on his coronation as senior chief (984 views)
- UPND bringing misery, they're praying against rains so that people kick out PF - Lungu
- Lusaka woman denies committing adultery with Patrick, Foreign Affairs PS
- Snake poison confusing Lungu, we've no powers to stop the rains - HH
- PF moves Parley motion to ban UPND for 'supporting gay rights'
- Police lied about Kaoma shooting, with impunity
Subscribe For News In Email
The News Diggers
Deputy News Editor
Plot No. Lus/9812/649-MC8
off Alex Chola Road
P.O. Box 32147
Telephone or WhatsApp:
diggers [at] diggers [dot] news
editor [at] diggers [dot] news
Send this to a friend