- by Natasha Sakala on 22 Aug 2019by Mukosha Funga on 21 Aug 2019by Ulande Nkomesha on 21 Aug 2019by Ulande Nkomesha on 21 Aug 2019
- by Ulande Nkomesha on 21 Aug 2019by Memory Chipili in Solwezi on 20 Aug 2019by Mukosha Funga on 19 Aug 2019by Natasha Sakala on 17 Aug 2019
- by Natasha Sakala on 21 Aug 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 21 Aug 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 21 Aug 2019by Zondiwe Mbewe on 21 Aug 2019
- Goal Diggers
- by Abraham Kalito on 8 Aug 2019by Abraham Kalito on 8 Aug 2019by Abraham Kalito on 5 Aug 2019by Abraham Kalito on 28 Jul 2019
- by Diggers Editor on 22 Aug 2019by Diggers Editor on 21 Aug 2019by Diggers Editor on 20 Aug 2019by Diggers Editor on 18 Aug 2019
- Guest Diggers
- by Chisoni Mumba, PhD on 17 Aug 2019by CUTS on 4 Aug 2019by Kangwa Muyunda on 3 Aug 2019by Rueben Lifuka on 31 Jul 2019
- Editor's Choice
- by Diggers Correspondent on 24 May 2019by Diggers Reporter on 4 Mar 2019by Andyford Mayele Banda on 29 Jan 2019by Davies Mwila on 22 Jan 2019
- by Diggers Correspondent on 11 Aug 2019by Mukosha Funga on 27 Jul 2019by Mukosha Funga on 21 Jul 2019by Web Master on 27 Jun 2019
It’s not the increase, mines are rejecting tax inconsistenciesBy Diggers Editor on 26 Feb 2019
We have noticed that those in government are finding it very easy to fool people into believing that mining companies are, without any reason, resisting to accept the mining tax increase brought about in the 2019 budget. With that argument, it can be understood why Copperbelt residents are showing their anger to their employers, vowing that they will not accept any retrenchment plans.
But the people of Zambia, especially those who earn their livelihoods from the mines on the Copperbelt, must understand this argument from both sides of the coin. Before they raise their axes to assault their employers, they must first understand what is giving mining companies the impetus to resist another mining tax policy change.
Technocrats say that the mining tax increase itself is marginal in real terms. But two things are cardinal to understand. First of all, we must admit that there is a lot of ill-motivated investment in the mining sector. It is true that foreigners are coming into this country with plans to dig holes and take out minerals without leaving anything tangible for the country.
The 2019 mining fiscal regime, which took effect last month, has seen an increase in mineral royalty rates by 1.5 percentage points at all levels of the sliding scale.
It also introduced import duties of five per cent on copper and cobalt, while also hiking export duty on precious stones and gemstones to a rate of 15 per cent, a situation that had previously prompted mining companies to threaten job cuts, while compelling Konkola Copper Mines (KCM) to downsize its Nchanga Smelter operations last month due to low availability of concentrates.
It is not in doubt that there is lack of transparency on the part of investors. Mining companies are not clean in their dealings. They may claim to be victims, but they are not innocent. There is a serious lack of full tax compliance from mining firms, through creative accounting and undervaluing tactics, which are depriving government the much-needed revenue.
But we feel government is allowing this to happen because its own house is not in order. If the government doesn’t have its house in order, there is no way it can succeed to put the mining house in order. For many years, this PF government has failed to have a comprehensive and long-term tax policy for the mining sector. This has exposed ineptitude and lack of expertise in tax policy framing and tax administration in government. What has made this mess more difficult to clean is that government has retired a lot of professional technocrats in the past few years. They have scandalized experts who understand the mining sector challenges, because they don’t want to be told the truth when they make a mistake.
Given the low trust levels in government by stakeholders, many people now believe that there is concealed private interest among those who walk the corridors of power to facilitate for a Chinese takeover of key mines. This message rings loud and clear through various media commentaries from government officials to the effect that mines can pack and go. Government proxies, including the Economics Association of Zambia (EAZ), have also echoed this message.
How do you say to mining companies that ‘you can pack and go’, and at the same time claim to be promoting a suitable climate for investment? This is what gives credence to even the unpopular positions taken by people like Hakainde Hichilema who seem to be siding with the mines’ position on the new tax regime. His argument is that this government doesn’t know what it is doing because it has no long-term plan for investment protection. It’s hard to disagree with Mr Hichilema because, indeed, this government is changing mine taxes like underwear.
This is the point that the Zambia Chamber of Mines has been stressing. From an investment point of view, inconsistent mining taxes are more injurious on a business than higher, but stable policy. It is not only costly to plan on a mine tax that can change with the firing and hiring of a Finance Minister, but it also repels prospective investors.
We are not sure if people have realised that just recently, mining companies were coerced at ‘gunpoint’ to drop their intentions to lay off staff. The government was even issuing statements, through the Ministry of Finance, on behalf of mining companies that there would be no retrenchments. It never happens like that! How can the Minister make a commitment on behalf of the investor, as if she is the one who pays salaries to the miners?
Kansanshi Mining Plc and the Kalumbila Minerals Limited were visiting by various wings of government; including Police, ZRA, Labour Commissioner, for over 10 days with even threats of arrests to mine directors! Should we go that far for an issue that is basically an investment matter that requires sitting on the table to discuss and negotiate using financial statements and other records in the hands of government?
ZCCM-IH sits on these boards and knows too well how much mining companies make! Now, mining companies are on queue sending messages that border on public relations: that they are here to stay and won’t lay off staff when they know too well that they are injured for prospective earnings, primarily due to import duties on copper concentrates.
Just in January, government is believed to have lost about US$10 million in revenue because of low output due to concentrate duties. This may explain the inconsistencies in messages among the Minister of Finance, Minister of Mines and the fired ZCCM IH boss, Dr Pius Kasolo.
Our point is that, before Zambians get misled on this issue and turn their anger on people who mean well for them, they must first appreciate what has been happening in the background. Once they understand the full picture, they will have good argument points against their employers.
About Diggers Editor
The Editor of News Diggers gets to decide what is published.
Email: editor [at] diggers [dot] news.
- Forget the Damn headline, did you get the message? - 22 Aug 2019
- Why should we cry to get development? - 21 Aug 2019
- We’re a hungry nation because we insist that maize is our staple food - 20 Aug 2019
- Lungu is in gear 5 of 2021 campaigns - 18 Aug 2019
- Where is Local Govt, LCC, while PF opens night street vending? - 16 Aug 2019
- Lungu leads 34 member delegation to India (2,264 views)
- Mushimba wonders why accepted UNZA student don’t show up to enroll (1,915 view)
- Ndulo, Sangwa must be drunk to think they can sue Lungu - Tutwa (1,636 view)
- You'll create constitutional crisis if you rule Matibini out of order on Roan seat, Mwansa tells ConCourt (1,601 view)
- State witness in Chimese’s case in court for perjury (1,024 view)
- Lungu was one of my brightest pupils, retired teacher tells court
- It's not LAZ but 2,3 overzealous lawyers challenging Bill 10 - Siliya
- Development will follow those who cry the most, says Lungu
- I'm suing Tutwa for alleging that I've been paid to fight govt - LAZ president
- Tutwa leads campaign to impeach LAZ president
Subscribe For News In Email
The News Diggers
Deputy News Editor
Plot No. Lus/9812/649-MC8
off Alex Chola Road
P.O. Box 32147
Telephone or WhatsApp:
diggers [at] diggers [dot] news
editor [at] diggers [dot] news
Send this to a friend