- Goal Diggers
- Guest Diggers
Vedanta asks Court of Appeal to allow arbitrationBy Zondiwe Mbewe on 16 Aug 2019
Vedanta Resources Holdings Limited has appealed to the Court of Appeal, against the Lusaka High Court’s refusal to stay the winding-up proceedings that ZCCM Investments Holdings has instituted against Konkola Copper Mines (KCM) and refer parties to arbitration.
Vedanta has further asked the Lusaka High Court to stay the Winding-up proceedings pending determination of it’s appeal.
In this matter, ZCCM-IH has petitioned the Lusaka High Court, seeking an order that KCM should be wound up for engaging in tax evasion and being managed in a manner detrimental to its interest, among other allegations.
Vedanta, the majority shareholder of KCM, had applied for an order to stay proceedings and refer the parties to arbitration pursuant to section 10 of the Arbitration Act.
But earlier this month, Lusaka High Court Judge Anessie Banda-Bobo dismissed Vedanta’s application saying it was not a proper case to refer the parties to arbitration.
She ruled that staying the proceedings at the instance of Vedanta would be contrary to the wishes of ZCCM-IH and KCM, who are the parties to the proceedings.
Justice Banda-Bobo observed that staying the proceedings and referring parties to arbitration would leave KCM’s creditors who had indicated their interest in the proceedings, without a remedy.
However, in a memorundum of appeal filed in the Court of Appeal, Vedanta argued in its grounds of appeal, among others, that justice Banda-Bobo erred in law and fact after finding that there was in fact an abitrable dispute between Vedanta and ZCCM-IH which is the subject of an arbitration agreement.
Vedanta further argued that justice Banda-Bobo erred in law and fact when she held that Vedanta as contributor, could not make the application to stay and refer parties to arbitration as it was not a party to the proceedings, a finding which is not consistent with the true interpretation of the Arbitration Act.
It also argued that Justice Banda-Bobo erred in law and fact when she concluded that KCM was a separate entity from Vedanta and that only KCM could defend itself in the winding-up proceedings.
And in an affidavit in support of ex parte summons for an order to stay proceedings pending the hearing of the appeal filed in the Lusaka High Court yesterday, Vedanta’s representative Hermein Uys asked the court to stay the winding-up proceedings stating that in the event that their appeal succeeds, the outcome would be rendered academic should the winding-up proceedings before the High Court proceed.
“This court has scheduled August 27 as date of hearing the petition of winding-up of KCM. That further in the event that the appeal lodged by the contributor in the Court of Appeal succeeds, the outcome of the appeal would be rendered academic should the winding-up proceedings before this court proceed and KCM be wound-up and in such a case, the contributor would be seriously prejudiced,” read the affidavit.
Uys stated that the Vedanta group had since 2004 provided over US$1 billion in the form of shareholders loans to KCM.
He added that the Vedanta group of which Vedanta was a member, was by far the largest creditor of KCM and therefore likely to suffer the greatest financial harm if the stay application was not granted.
“That the Vedanta group has since 2004 provided over US$1 billion in the form of shareholder loans to the respondent. Further it has provided guarantee for certain loans and credit facilities from third party banks and also guaranteed a US$100 million advance payment made by one of KCM’s customers,” read the affidavit further.
“The Vedanta group (of which the contributor is a member) is by far the largest creditor of the respondent and therefore likely to suffer the greatest financial harm if the stay application is not granted. In so far as I am aware and I verily believe it to be so that the petitioner will not suffer harm as it had not invested any amounts in the respondent in that period.”
Uys further stated that if the appeal that Vedanta had filed succeeds, then the proceedings before the High Court would be stayed and the matter reffered to arbitration.
“That if the petition for the winding-up of the respondent will proceed to be heard and determined despite the pending appeal by the contributor in the court of appeal, then the said appeal will be rendered academic and a nugatory. It is desirable and in the interest of justice that all further proceedings before this court be stayed pending the hearing and determination of the appeal by the court of appeal,” read the affidavit.
Meanwhile, another creditor of KCM Jersey Limited has filed a notice of intetion to appear on the petition persuant to rule 10 of the companies winding-up rules.
“Take note that Vedanta Resources Jersey II Limited, a creditor who is owed a sum of US $1,038,300,000.00 plus interest , intends to appear on the hearing of the aforementioned petition to oppose it when the said petiton is presented for hearing,” read the notice filed by Messers Mulenga Mundashi Legal Practitioners.
About Zondiwe Mbewe
Zondiwe has interest in writing political and current affairs on issues which affect every Zambians.
Email: zondiwe [at] diggers [dot] news
- Soko not entitled to any of his claims, RTSA tells court - 21 Feb 2020
- Kambwili has the right to criticize govt, ZNBC staffer tells court - 21 Feb 2020
- ConCourt throws out LAZ’s application to jail Tutwa for contempt - 21 Feb 2020
- Court orders release of IMS boss’ passport - 20 Feb 2020
- $1m claim in costs by Rephidim, 2 others is inflated, says Vedanta - 20 Feb 2020
- PF official gets terrorism charges over gassing (7,124 views)
- Those lying about knowing gassing masterminds will be charged for causing alarm, warns IG (5,874 views)
- Please China, spare us from Coronavirus (4,769 views)
- Where is the father while the mother weeps “amwa peeling?” (2,800 views)
- Lungu renews Bible Society membership, as netizens drag him back to gassing (2,305 views)
Subscribe for news email alerts
ArchivesMar0 PostsApr0 PostsMay0 PostsJun0 PostsJul0 PostsAug0 PostsSep0 PostsOct0 PostsNov0 PostsDec0 Posts
- «February 2020»
- February 2020
- January 2020
- December 2019
- November 2019
- October 2019
- September 2019
- August 2019
- July 2019
- June 2019
- May 2019
- April 2019
- March 2019
- February 2019
- January 2019
- December 2018
- November 2018
- October 2018
- September 2018
- August 2018
- July 2018
- June 2018
- May 2018
- April 2018
- March 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
- November 2017
- October 2017
- September 2017
- August 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
- Disband Religion Ministry, Sumaili’s actions border on lawlessness
- Mobs kill four more, as police nab 14 for murder
- The real ritual killer is The Mob
- Those lying about knowing gassing masterminds will be charged for causing alarm, warns IG
- Please China, spare us from Coronavirus
- Careless comments on gassing will breed chaos – ZCCB
- PF official gets terrorism charges over gassing
- It’s every man for himself under Lungu – Milupi
- ACC probes Health Minister for corruption
- Chilubi outcome shows 2021 polls won’t be free and fair – AVAP
- Criminals are changing tactics, soldiers can’t root them out instantly – Chama
- Bill 10 has polarized Zambia – Kabimba
The News Diggers
Deputy News Editor
Send this to a friend